
We’re proud to present to our readership our picks for the year’s best albums. From soaring acoustic worship to straight-ahead rock & roll, we’ve done our best to choose albums that did well in the market as well as pushed the envelope of creativity for the artist and the genre they represent (if they can even be categorized). Let us know your thoughts. Agree? Disagree? Did we miss something? Let us know your picks!
#1. NEEDTOBREATHE’S The Outsiders showcases a band that has found its identity: outsiders who don’t fit neatly into anyone’s boxes, but can connect with most. Masterfully blending earnest lyrics with elements of southern rock and a modern rock sound all their own, Needtobreathe has produced easily their finest work to date, and our choice for best album of the year.
#2. Relient K’s Forget and Not Slow Down is everything an album should be and the vast majority of albums are not. It has a cohesive concept and tone without the filler songs most albums cling too. It doesn’t feel like a collection of singles with a few B-sides thrown into the mix, and yet every song is worthy of radio airplay. While not overly experimental the album has clear inspiration that it builds from and does not mimic.
#3. Decyfer Down’s Crash rocks my face off. From the opening track “Crash” with its crunchy guitars and raspy vocals to the album’s melodically pensive closer “Forever With You,” this is simply a solid effort that can be enjoyed by people who love rocking out without having to have their sense assaulted by so much of the garbage that accompanies rock music today. And while Decyfer Down skimps on the sex & drugs part of the equation, they will melt your face off with their go-ahead rock sound. They leave nothing to be desired, grinding out their music with the verve and dedication of a band 10 years their senior.
#4. Israel Houghton’s The Power of One bursts at the seams with visions of victory in Jesus, awe in worship, and a reverent respect for a holy king. It is very clear that while Houghton knows that we are now each considered a “friend of God,” there is still an awe and respect with which we must approach the throne of grace. Additionally, the victorious songs never get mired in the idea that it is our victory (but rather victory belongs to Jesus) and the somber songs never get stuck in a “woe-is-me” attitude.
#5. Kutless’ It Is Well is the new worship album from Kutless, a group typically known for their rock style. The album has both covers and originals that blend the edge they are known for and the music of today’s typical contemporary worship service. This is Kutless’ second worship release. Their first, Strong Tower touted the single of the same name that made its way up the Christian music radio charts. As a result, expectations were. In my opinion, they exceeded those expectations.
#6. Shane & Shane’s Everything Is Different will put a smile on your face. With any luck it will bring you to a place where you can pause and come nearer to our God and King. Shane and Shane put all they have into writing and producing songs that will stir and inspire us, and they don’t miss a beat with this album. If you want to experience lyrics that draw you to God in an intimate way, this album has the power to do just that.
#7. Skillet’s Awake builds on the foundation laid by Collide and Comatose and delivers more of what fans have come to know and love from the foursome. Is it more of the same? Sure. But, their current formula has built them a solid fanbase that will certainly be pleased with this latest offering.
#8. Thousand Foot Krutch’s Welcome to the Masquerade is a nearly perfect album, it is filled with a few simply wonderful and noteworthy songs. As an album, it might just be superior as individual songs. Fans should love this album. It doesn’t suffer in terms of quality of sound. A surprisingly hard album, it fundamentally is an excellent work that has stunning production and a crisp rich sound.
#9. Mat Kearney’s City of Black & White has the opportunity to take the airwaves by storm. Kearney’s music has always been hard to describe, but easy on the ears. Think of his earlier work in terms of Coldplay reinvented as a hip hop act.
#10. Flyleaf’s Memento Mori isn’t something new, and it isn’t drastically different. But it is a good album, and shows the talent this young group of people have. Flyleaf has successfully avoided the dreaded sophomore slump, and this release is a worthy chapter in their short career.




Gotta say I’m extremely happy to see Needtobreathe on top there. I absolutely loved The Outsiders, and it was definitely my favorite album of the year. Pretty great year for music all around really.
I am not against any of these picks, but Phil Wickham’s “Heaven and Earth” is on top for me, and Sara Groves’ “Fireflies and Songs” is somewhere in the top 10. If only 12 albums could fit in the top 10.
I’m a little surprised. No SCC? No Switchfoot? This was a year of really good albums so it’s hard to choose. I’ve been thinking about my “best of” list this year. I felt Bethany Dillon’s album was great. As were Jars of Clay and Derek Webb.
I too am (a little) surprised at a couple notable snubs. David Crowder Band, Switchfoot, Phil Wickham, Emery, and Derek Webb (and I’m sure one contributor to this site will be slightly perturbed about that one, in particular…). I wasn’t really overly impressed with Relient K or Kutless, but I know a lot of people were, so I’m not sure where you would’ve fit those snubs in. But those were the (sort of) surprises for me.
I too wish that DCB and Switchfoot could have made this list, but am happy with the picks. I might have switched Flyleaf with either DCB and Switchfoot.
No Derek Webb? Like, at all? Even as an honorable mention?
No U2?
No David Crowder? Even if I wasn’t the biggest fan, it’s still David Crowder. And it got killer reviews here when it dropped.
No Switchfoot?
No Sleeping at Last?
And I wrote the Mat Kearney review for TCM. The album was horrible.
Which staff selected the material for the list?
I agree some of those should have been on there (although I disagree on U2 – didn’t connect with that at all), but the Mat Kearney album wasn’t horrible. Top 10? Maybe not, but definitely not “horrible.”
I would have liked to have seen some of the aforementioned bands on here, too. This was the opinion of one person and I felt it was a pretty solid year so we went with it. However, next year’s process will be a little more rigorous. Let’s just hope it’s a bad year for music or no matter WHAT we do, someone is gonna be surprised or upset. But, trust me, no one was “snubbed” and an honorable mention category is now FULLY planned for the 2010 Lime Awards.
I meant “snubs” in the way that it’s always talked about when all-star teams are picked. Didn’t look at it as disrespect or anything. Any list like this is going to leave out some good ones. It’s inevitable. We’re all gonna have our opinions about who should/shouldn’t have made it. That’s what makes music so interesting.
Sorry Calvin but I have to completely disagree with this list.
COMPLETELY? As in, NONE of the bands on this list should have even been nominated? While I don’t completely agree with the rankings and think some artists (i.e. Jars of Clay, Switchfoot, Fiction Family, Tedashii, Derek Webb, Goodnight House) are conspicuously absent, I still believe the albums included are of note and deserve some form of recognition. We could go round and round as to whether they are Top 10 material or just honorable mention, but I still think each album was noteworthy (even if I didn’t personally compose this year’s list). NEXT year, this will be a more communal process, but will take more time.
Dan Westfall,
While I don’t necessarily agree with this entire list either, what would you have liked to see?
There are the obvious (Switchfoot, DCB) albums that could be added, if you COMPLETELY disagree with this list, lets hear yours.
Yeah, this list really needed Switchfoot, jars of clay, the fray, and Mutemath should all be on here
Calvin and Jose: Once my final exams are over, I will compile my list. Needless to say, I am not a huge fan of the lack of creativity of most Christian bands, so I am probably just annoyed by this list more than in actual disagreement. Also, I agree that DCB and Switchfoot are missing. They killed it this year. Now to study for a slew of finals.
Do you know what I want to see…
The Top 10 surprises and the top 10 disappointments, as well as the top 10 debuts.
As in a list of acts who have really matured or really want to hear from next year, another lists of veterans who really should have done better, and finally a list of ‘ones to watch’…
Just an idea!
But on this– MAJOR lack of DCB and Sara Groves. Personally Israel’s CD was good, but not even a Top 15. For sure…
Really guys, come on. Y’all mention DCB and Switchfoot. Do y’all want a list of 2009 Music that had the most hype or actually the BEST music of 2009. Both DCB and Switchfoot had HYPE and there were many other good albums (some which are not on this list, some which are).
DCB’s church music was un-listenable (if thats a word) as well as being of poor audio quality. It really hurt my ears.
Switchfoot is HYPED to much. Those are my Finalito Thougititos!
I don’t like this list at all. I agree with Dan’s sentiment that Christian bands and artists tend to lack creativity. I’d really like to see what he’d put on his list.
Since reviews on this site aren’t limited to just Christian musicians, it’s odd to me that every artist on this list would be Christian. Was there a reason that non-Christian albums weren’t included? Also, I find it humorous how the writer described Flyleaf’s album. He/she doesn’t make it sound like “Top 10″ material…
Tom,
This was our first attempt. Next year will be better, we promise.
Tom,
I actually wrote the flyleaf review. To clarify, I thought it was a good album. While I wouldn’t consider it top ten material, it’s still worth a listen. To be honest, I would have had a drastically different list, but that’s all personal opinion